State governments should leave regulation of the Internet to the
federal government, which in turn should largely let Web business operate
as a free market, Federal Communications Commission Chairman Michael
Powell said.
"The Internet desperately needs to enjoy fairly uniform regulatory
treatment," Powell told lawyers at the Washington- based non-profit
Federalist Society. "I personally believe the market is the best standard
on which the Internet runs."
The FCC has scheduled a Dec. 1 hearing on regulating use of the
Internet to route telephone calls with a technology known as "voice over
Internet protocol," or VOIP, which is less expensive than traditional
phone service. Powell has said the FCC will soon start considering rules
on how Web calling should be overseen.
California state regulators met today to discuss VOIP-related rules. In
Minnesota, a federal judge said last month that the state's regulators
can't classify Internet call-router Vonage Holdings Corp. as a local phone
company to regulate it more closely.
"Internet service has been a regulatory-free zone, and I don't see any
problem with that for the foreseeable future," said Billy Jack Gregg, head
of West Virginia's state consumer advocacy unit. "The states should stay
out unless there's a demonstrated problem with Internet access, which
actually has gotten better -- not worse -- over the years."
Shares of companies that seek to serve the Internet phone market, such
as SpectraLink Corp. and Sonus Networks Inc., have risen with increased
demand for VOIP systems. Their competitors include
Cisco Systems Inc.,
Comcast Corp. and Avaya Inc.
Powell, a Republican appointed by President George W. Bush, said state
regulatory efforts "could suck the life force out of Internet development"
by imposing "multiple and competing rules."
The rules could add cost and complexity to Web businesses, while
impeding company growth and innovation, he said.