|Lost In IVR:
The Hidden Costs Of Pushing High-Value Customers Through Self-Service
By Lois Brown, Austin Logistics Inc.
'Your call will be answered in the order received.' These nine
little words could be the most costly words spoken to customers today.
Yet, every day this phrase, or some variation, is voiced millions of times
to customers who are routed through Interactive Voice Response (IVR)
systems. After a decade of widespread IVR technology implementation '
primarily in the pursuit of speed and cost savings ' the actual message
that customers who are lost in long wait queues and endless feedback loops
are hearing is, 'You don't matter to us.'
The result is a costly backlash. 'By stressing speed over service,
call centers virtually guarantee they'll end up annoying customers
instead of helping them,' stated a Harvard Business Review report1. Is it any wonder more customers are hanging up,
permanently disconnecting their relationships with companies that no
longer appear to value their relationships?
Customer relationship termination is only one of the high costs of
today's proliferation of one-size-fits-all IVR systems. Not only are
companies failing to achieve the low-cost, high-profit rewards they
expected, but worse, several strategic profit-generating opportunities are
being lost. These business losses include opportunities to deepen customer
loyalty, achieve higher agent productivity and increase upselling and
cross-selling. These losses are, in fact, the hidden costs of IVR. And
very few companies today can continue to afford them.
The profit-damaging impact of today's standard first in-first out IVR
is exacerbated even further when you consider your high-value customers.
What might be annoying to low-value customers, such as long waits in IVR,
could be deadly to high-value customers ' and, therefore, lethal to your
business. They will be the most intolerant of a disconnected relationship.
When their needs aren't met in a timely fashion, they will be the first
ones to terminate their relationship with you and find another company
that will better meet their needs. Yet they are often kept waiting behind
a sea of low-value frequent callers, or they are left alone to close their
accounts in self-service without first hearing a retention offer from a
Fortunately, there is now a way to address the hidden costs of IVR:
call centers can employ predictive, pre-agent routing technology to manage
customer value on every incoming call. This simple yet powerful solution
can turn your current IVR system into an intelligent powerhouse that helps
build customer satisfaction, expand selling opportunities and optimize
agent scheduling ' and finally elevate your call center into the profit
center you always wanted.
This article will reveal what you may currently be losing in IVR, and
it will show how you can use intelligent model-driven predictive
technologies to identify who's calling, estimate the caller's future
value and evaluate his or her reaction to various levels of treatment '
before the caller permanently hangs up on you.
Loyal Relationships With High-Value Customers
The proliferation of self-service technology during the past decade has
brought an increase in customer control. Today your customers decide when
and how they interact with you. According to a Bearing Point report on
call centers and customer service, 'the push for self-service in the
name of cost savings and expediency over recent years has given customers
unprecedented power over the relationship.' And they are exercising this
power by going elsewhere when they don't like the service they are
If your customers are only doing business with you at arms-length
through your IVR, and the system doesn't quickly deliver the experience
they like, your relationship could be permanently damaged. For example,
they may become so irritated they will be unreceptive to any future
upselling or cross-selling, no matter how good the deals are. They may
purchase from one of your competitors without learning that you offer a
better product or a better deal. They may complain about you to friends,
to family or on the Web. What's more, they may attrite without ever
giving you a chance to encourage their loyalty.
A growing number of research studies reveal the extent of this customer
relationship problem. For example, the American Management Association
found 68 percent of clients stop doing business with a company because of
poor service. According to StreetTalk by CQ Research, 20 percent of the
general population has stopped using credit cards because of too long of a
wait when calling into customer service. For high-income, high-value
customers, the loss climbs to 26 percent.
While it's clear that poor customer service negatively impacts your
business, it's equally clear that good customer service significantly
improves business by deepening customer relationships, building loyalty,
reducing silent attrition and churn, helping retain more customers.
However, it's not cost-effective for call centers to aim for improving
service to all customers; instead, the ideal target to aim for is your
high-value customers. These are the people who represent long-term
purchasing opportunities, who are potentially the most loyal, who are the
most responsive to upselling and who are the most willing to recommend
companies to others ' when they're happy with the service they
Many call centers are attempting to reinforce these relationships using
silver, gold and platinum plus-style programs, special 800 numbers,
special agent queues or special promotional offers. But these efforts are
not enough. Even in a premium customer queue, the third caller to arrive
may be more impatient than the first caller; therefore, his or her future
value and loyalty may be much more dependent upon how long he or she waits
than the first caller.
To truly support high-value customers, you must proactively drive each
high-value inbound caller to the right service level every time he or she
calls. This way you can ensure your agents speak with the appropriate
customers quickly ' including the best cross-sell prospects, those at
greatest risk for attrition or those with the highest potential future
value. To achieve this goal, you need an intelligent predictive solution
that answers several strategic customer questions including:
- How long will a caller be willing to wait before hanging up?
- How long will a caller wait before taking his or her business to
- When will an agent connection pay off in future customer revenue?
- Who is likely to attrite if you don't take proactive steps?
- Which customers will attrite, no matter what you do?
Opportunities To Upsell And Cross-Sell
The second critical opportunity lost in IVR is the chance to upsell and
cross-sell to your customers. While your goal may be to complete more
calls in self-service, there are times when you can increase revenue by
rescuing callers from the IVR and sending them to a sales agent. But not
every customer is a candidate. To leverage this lost opportunity, you need
a pre-agent routing technology that predicts the answers to critical
customer-behavior questions such as:
- Who will be the most responsive to a cross-sell offer?
- Who will stay a loyal customer if an agent made him or her a
- Could the same offer be made as effectively in IVR?
- Would he or she refuse a cross-sell or accept it and, as a result,
become a more loyal customer?
- How long will he or she be willing to wait before becoming so
irritated he or she is unreceptive to any cross-sell offer?
Optimized Agent Productivity
The third opportunity lost in IVR is the ability to achieve optimum agent
productivity, including leveling agent workloads during peak calling
times, fully using your high-cost agent resources and lowering overall
costs. The typical solution ' hiring more agents to reduce hold times in
a FIFO system ' is not the answer because low-value callers can still
clog your system and keep high-value, wait-intolerant customers waiting.
What's needed instead is action-specific modeling to identify exactly
the calls on which your scarce agent resources will have the greatest
impact. This will enable your agents to spend more time with your most
With an intelligent predictive solution assessing each caller for
proactive call routing, each inbound call is given the proper level of
service ' whether retention agent, sales agent, IVR or callback message.
In this way, you can avoid the cost of building up agent resources for
peak times. No matter how many or how few agents you have, you will ensure
that your high-value, treatment-responsive callers are getting the
attention they need to keep them happy and to increase their value.
Intelligent Predictive Actions Lead To Higher Profits
Knowing the future value of customers ' including who will and who
won't be profitable, as well as who is likely to churn or respond to a
marketing offer ' and integrating this information into your call center
operations is the key to achieving optimum profitability. How can you
discover the opportunities currently lost in your IVR system? Here's a
powerful four-step process:
- Select Your Strategy. Using predictive, model-driven technologies
begins by choosing your primary objective: increasing cross-selling
and upselling, reducing attrition and resources or a combination.
- Employ Action-Specific Models. You need to identify high-value
customers and treat them in ways that harvest their maximum value '
whether through near-zero wait times, pre-emptive retention offers or
appropriate cross-sell offers. Potential value is the key.
Action-specific modeling is required to predict how each caller will
react to all of the various treatment options you could employ. In
this way, you identify the best treatment to maximize the value of
- Deploy In Real-Time. The system must be able to access all necessary
databases for customer information in real-time, as each call comes
in, and immediately tag each call for proper treatment in three areas:
- Service levels: live agent or VRU resolution;
- Call routing: agent skill set, retention agent or sales agent; and
- Priority ordering: zero/short wait or longer wait when agent
capacity is constrained.
- The system should also continually monitor agent queue depth,
keeping it low for optimum queue management.
- Measure Your Success. Your solution needs to collect vital
information during the call and then report back to you after the call
is completed. It should be able to tell you if the callers, in fact,
made a cross-purchase, accepted the retention offer, kept their
accounts open, increased their purchase levels or performed the
profit-driven action you have set as an objective. These measurements
should be hard numbers, such as reduced attrition, increased sales and
lower resource costs ' not merely soft results such as self-reported
satisfaction. In this way, you'll have a highly accurate ROI
accounting and a mechanism for continual improvement.
It is clear that to build profits in your call center, your goal cannot
be only to complete more calls in self-service. Instead, you need an
intelligent way to predict the future behavior of all incoming callers
based on how you treat them. And you need a way to drive each call to the
right service level every time. The bottom line? When your high-value
customers call, make sure that rather than hearing 'Your call will be
answered in the order received,' resulting in them hanging up and
thinking you don't care, your intelligent actions, instead, loudly and
clearly communicate the one message always critical to superior customer
relations: 'We value your business.'
1Arussy, Lior. 'Don't Take Calls, Make
Contact.' Harvard Business Review, January 1, 2002.
Lois Brown is vice president of marketing at Austin Logistics Inc.,
headquartered in Austin, Texas. She oversees brand positioning, marketing
communications and new product definition for the company's expanding
line of call center analytic software and custom modeling services. Austin
Logistics helps companies increase the value of customer interactions,
simplify operations and help achieve business-specific objectives in the
areas of collections, risk management and customer service.
[Return To The August 2004 Table Of