Yet
Another Post-Mortem Of The Dot Com Phenomenon
I was listening to NPR one morning last week, as
usual. I usually listen with only three-quarters of my attention, the
remaining quarter devoted to tooth brushing, picking white cat hair off
dark clothing, taking something out of the freezer for dinner, and
checking the temperature to find out whether to wear an extra fuzzy
sweater. That particular morning, however, NPR had all my attention.
James Ledbetter, the former European bureau chief of
the now-defunct Industry Standard, has written a book called,
Starving To Death On $200 Million, a post-mortem of the death of
that spectacularly debuted magazine that went down in a whimper a mere two
years later. He was discussing his new book with an NPR interviewer. If
walls had sensitivities to naughty language, the paint would have been
peeling off mine that morning.
As a result, I toyed with the idea of naming my
column of this week, How To Turn Moaning And Blamestorming Into A
Cottage Industry.
I remember the kind of parties Ledbetter talked about
when he discussed the early, wildly successful days of both the e-commerce
industry and the Industry Standardpress launches, cocktail
parties at trade shows, annual meeting receptions. The editors from the Industry
Standard were the ones doing the conga line around the ice sculpture,
glass of Dom Perignon in hands. My colleagues and I were the ones standing
in the corner, gawking at the excess, betting how long it would be before
the gravy train ended.
We spent a lot of money on something called
customer relationship management software, said Ledbetter, which is
something I wont even begin to explain, but suffice it to say it
didnt work.
Clearly, sir youre not going to begin to
explain it because you likely didnt understand it to begin with.
It didnt work, I imagine, because those who were supposed to be
learning how to use it were too busy shopping for Porsches. Heres a
secretcustomer relationship management software isnt going to run
your company while youre out getting your butt kissed by the venture
capital guys.
Despite the death of the Industry Standard,
Ledbetter indicated that, There remains a great appetite for Internet
business. He cites the successes of Amazon.com
(which in reality has a spotty record of success) and Napster and Kazaa (one of them has been shut down by
lawsuits, the other one has just recently had the first lawsuits filed
against itand besides, teenaged file swappers were very likely NOT
reading publications like the Industry Standard).
Hes right, of course, that the market still has a
huge appetite for goods and services bought over the Internet. Im
starting to have a bit of a problem with e-commerce, though. I dont
order nearly as much off the Internet as I used to, particularly now in a
tighter economy, and I wonder how many others are like me. Mostly, this is
due to some experiences Ive had recently.
It may be no secret to many of you that there are few
bargains on domestic flights right now. What we need is a really good
price war to get things low again. Regardless, Ive been on the hunt for
round-trip tickets from New York to New Orleans, and have yet to come up
with any price that really pleases me. So I logged onto Priceline.comIve never used
their service for flights before, and I was faintly curious about what
they would come up with. I followed their instructions on bidding for
flights, entered my information, andmy bid got rejected. I got a
helpful e-mail, though, telling me that they could offer me round trip
tickets for the low price of $196.00, including tax.
What a bargain! American Airlines is offering a
direct flight, at the times I pick myself, for $186.50. Sofor the
privilege of not being able to choose my flight times or my airline,
Priceline would be happy to accommodate me by charging me $10 more than
buying them directly from my preferred carrier. When I informed them of
this via e-mail, I got a patronizing auto-reply message: Were sorry
youre disappointed with your Priceline experience. Chances are
pretty good that no one with a decision-making job function will ever see
my e-mail, or understand the fairly uncomplicated principle that if
youre purporting to be a discounter of airline tickets, its kind of
important that you actually offer discounts. Same goes with the big three:
Travelocity, Expedia and Orbitz, all of whom now seem incapable of
beating the prices on flights purchased directly from the carriers.
My second experience involves an order I still have
pending from long before the holidays. I ordered some prints and mattes as
Christmas gifts. I received two mattes and one print on about December 21st,
a few days after I placed the order. I had received an e-mail telling me
that my entire order had been received (which presumably means it went
into their system). Im still waiting for the balance of my order. My
credit card number has not been charged for the unshipped materials, and I
have yet to receive any notification of whats going on. My two query
e-mails have gone unanswered. Im a bit curious to find out when, or if,
theyre going to bother processing my order, or if theyre going to
let me know if theyre ever going to get around to taking my money. Must
be nice to be so flush you can pick and choose when, and if, you decide to
fill your customers orders.
Even Ledbetters Gold Standard, Amazon.com, has
showed a particular brand of cluelessness lately. I recently had a $20
gift certificate from Borders books, so I dropped by a store on a quiet
Sunday and browsed through their DVD titles. I ultimately settled on a
three-DVD set of my favorite BBC mystery, Cadfael, based on the
books by Ellis Peters about a mystery-solving 12th-century monk
in Shrewsbury Abbey (but to quote Peter Graves, thats not important
right now.) The total came to $41 and change, which required me to pony up
the $21 difference after my gift certificate was applied. I left pleased
with my purchase, which put the finishing touch on a lovely Sunday evening
spent in sweatpants drinking tea with the heat cranked up (its
currently colder than the surface of Neptune in the Northeast right now).
I was so pleased I decided to find out about acquiring another DVD set of
the same show, so I visited Amazon. With taxes and shipping, I would have
paid over $50 for the same DVD collection, with a two-day shipping option.
Do you remember the days when Amazon used to discount
their merchandise? I do. Is not having to stop at the bookstore worth
paying more than $10 extra per order? Not on your life. Browsing through a
bookstore is hardly a painful experiencemost people, including myself,
rather enjoy it. On top of it, Borders throws in the ability to get a cup
of coffee and listen to some live music while browsing. The ultimate irony
is that Borders and Amazon are partners, and when you visit www.borders.com, you end up essentially
redirected to Amazon.
Few people are forming new companies with the
Internet as their primary means of delivery. In a slow economy, with the
kind of suspicion the business world reserves for anything related to
e-commerce, its no wonder. In the not very distant future, however,
Im predicting the rise of a new order of new Web-based companies that
will come in strong and hard to challenge the status quoreal customer
service, real discounts, and business processes that have been trimmed of
all fat. When it happens, Ill be happy to write about these new
companies.
Ill even be happy to attend their press launches,
and sip a glass of moderately priced red wine and nibble store-brand chips
and salsa.
The author can be reached for comment at tschelmetic@tmcnet.com, but
thats not important right now, either.
|