Qualcomm�s new pdQ smartphone mobile
phone/PDA hybrid is the first device in its class that the public should
take seriously, in our humble opinion. There have been incremental steps:
the $900 Nokia 9000i Communicator debuted about a year ago, but it was too
big and too proprietary, and the $400 Neopoint phone is now available, but
it has a questionable learning curve and limited Internet functions. The
pdQ, priced at about $800, integrates a real, licensed Palm III with a
real, already ubiquitous Qualcomm telephone. From Bond to Gates, everyone
seems to agree that this class of device is our near future. We in TMC
Labs concur, and we add: the pdQ is the first one that�s done right.
INSTALLATION
Our pdQ was a 1900 model, which is the digital version � the pdQ is also
available in a dual-band version, called the 800. Either way, the basic
setup tasks include choosing your service plan, configuring your voice
mail, and programming your e-mail settings. Fortunately, your vendor
configures network settings for Web browsing, so it �just works� when
you turn it on. Beyond this, the only setup task is configuring the
screen, but that�s a standard (and very simple) part of using any Palm
device for the first time.
We had some initial difficulty configuring the e-mail settings. The
applications handbook was informative (see the documentation section
below), but the specific parts related to configuring e-mail could stand
some improvement. What pdQ users need to understand is that, unlike the
Palm.Net service used with the Palm VII, the pdQ�s e-mail settings rely
on your own ISP, not on the product manufacturer or the wireless provider
� in other words, Qualcomm and Sprint just make the phone and provide
wireless calling � e-mail is your own responsibility.
But that�s good news! You can use any POP3/SMTP provider, or even an
IMAP provider, if you obtain shareware to do that. Plus, unlike the Palm
VII where mail is delivered as being from [email protected], the pdQ method
allows you to send mail from a �real� account, which can be your own
company or almost any ISP. The bad news � and the reason we mention
e-mail at all in this section � is that the provided instructions aren�t
very good. For our version of better directions on configuring your pdQ�s
e-mail account, see the sidebar.
DOCUMENTATION
The pdQ includes an Applications Handbook, a Basics Handbook, a Graffiti
wallet card, two Graffiti reference stickers (one of which goes on the
inside of the pdQ�s dialpad), and a Quick Start Card. There is also a
help file within the pdQ itself, plus Web-based documents, including five FAQs
at www.qualcomm.com/pdQ/faq.
These cover the product itself, specific features, the Palm functions,
accessories, and technical support issues. Except for the e-mail
configuration mentioned above, the manuals are quite good, and we like
that they tend to focus on the features that are pdQ-specific (as opposed
to the standard telephony and Palm feature sets).
FEATURES
The most exciting features of the pdQ are the integrated address book and
the Internet functions. The address book makes good use of screen pops and
�true� CTI. If a call arrives and the caller�s phone number matches
a number in your address book, then the associated name will display. It
works in the other direction, too: you enter a telephone number using
either the Palm�s �Dialer� application or the traditional method,
and the associated address book name will display before you press the
physical call button (or before you tap the Palm �Talk� button).
And, because the address book is a standard Palm application, you can
use the included Palm Desktop software (Figure 1) (or your choice of
third-party software) to synchronize (HotSync) the pdQ with Exchange,
Outlook, GoldMine, ACT!, etc. We offer a tip: by synchronizing the entire
contents of your traditional Palm device with your PC and resynchronizing
the PC with your pdQ, you can essentially back-up all of your old data to
the new device.
There are many other address book features. For example, you can create
99 speed-dial entries, and changing a phone number in the address book
automatically changes the number in the associated speed-dial entry as
well. You can make conference calls by pressing the flash key, or by
tapping the flash button if the dialpad is open. There is a keyguard
feature to prevent accidental dialing, plus a restrict option that
requires a passcode to use the device at all. We�re also fond of the �pdQalert�
feature which performs screen pop duties when pages or SMS (text) messages
arrive, or when you have voice mail. Senders can include hyperlinks, which
open the pdQ�s Web browser when you tap them.
We have mixed feelings about the pdQmail application. As we have
mentioned, we love that the ISP (and thus the e-mail address) is yours to
choose, rather than being supplied exclusively by Qualcomm or by your
wireless provider, and we like that the application can display rich text
format. Messages with attachments are indicated as such, but the actual
attachments cannot be displayed. The ability to do so, we think, will be
one advantage of similar devices that are based on Windows CE.
We had mixed feelings about other areas as well: pdQmail offers
impressive message filtering and mailbox options, but messages cannot be
beamed using the IR port. Furthermore, you can configure pdQmail to
remember your account password or to require you to enter it manually, but
you cannot mark e-mail as private when you send it. (If Bill Gates is
truly smart, he�d port Outlook to the Palm OS, just as many other
Microsoft applications are ported to Apple operating systems.)
The pdQbrowser also has a split personality. Unlike the browsers found
in other mobile telephones and hybrid devices, which only let you browse
HDML sites, the pdQbrowser lets you go to any site. Some of its features
include: bookmarks that can be organized into categories, the ability to
launch mailto: and application-specific URLs, text that you can copy and
paste into other applications, and a �Details� screen for every site
visited. However, like most of the Web appliance browsers, the pdQbrowser
does not support any kind of Java, so sites that feature applets like
e-mail, product ordering, special effects, and related elements will not
display correctly.
One other comment: the five shortcut icons on the screen�s right side
adjust the contrast, power the phone on and off, open the call history
application, open pdQmail, and start HotSync. This is a nice touch, but
unfortunately, it makes the screen slightly narrower than that of a
standalone Palm device. As a result, some third-party applications and
even some Palm-optimized Web sites may not display correctly. A Qualcomm
executive who we interviewed denies this.
The remainder of the pdQ�s feature set consists of standard mobile
phone and Palm III features. Because these features are not new, we won�t
cover them here (if you�ve never used a Palm III, please see our October
1998 review at www.tmcnet.com/articles/ctimag/1098/palm.htm). Meanwhile,
to provide your bulleted-list fix, here are some other pdQ features:
- �Owner�s
Club�.
- Palm applications: calculator, date book, expense tracking,
HackMaster, PalmMail, memopad.
- Modem emulator software.
- Standard Palm physical scroll buttons.
- Included hands-free headset.
- Training software on CD-ROM.
- Includes three extra styluses and charging cradle.
- CDMA technology.
OPERATIONAL TESTING
For the ultimate real-world test, a TMC Labs engineer agreed to use the
pdQ for a week in place of his personal mobile telephone. Actually, �agreed�
is not the right word � he drooled over it and threw a tantrum when it
was time to return the device to Sprint. But we didn�t mind: we figured
that if the pdQ could so enthrall one of our own, imagine how much it
would impress the readers! (Editor�s note: that engineer has since taped
a paper cup to his cubicle wall with the text �Please help � pdQ fund�
scrawled on the side in block letters.)
Other than this temporary setback in our engineer�s happiness, we
were very impressed with the pdQ�s operation. Anyone who�s used a
late-model mobile telephone and a Palm device will find the pdQ extremely
easy to learn. You probably wouldn�t use the Web browser for long-term
surfing or late-night �just browsing� sessions, but for on-the-fly
needs like driving directions, stock quotes, news, and sports scores, the
browser is perfectly suitable.
More importantly, as VARs and developers make custom sites designed for
applications like sales force automation, remote diagnostics, database
queries, and more, the pdQ will become increasingly useful. True, you can
use the browser to order a book from Amazon.com, but if the pdQ ever gets
Java or multimedia, then a creative programmer can turn it into a remote
call center tool or a unified messaging client. (In theory, an HTML
version of a unified messaging client could be done today by using
off-the-shelf SDKs. If you develop one, let us know.)
ROOM FOR IMPROVEMENT
As much as we like the pdQ, no product is perfect. Beside the Java and
multimedia functions, which are probably still at least a year away,
several other features would make the pdQ more usable. We�d like to see
a full-size Palm display, a folding backside prop (for using the pdQ in an
upright position on airplane trays), and a fixed-position antenna (many
mobile phones use these in place of extendable antennae). Inconsequential
and memory-hogging as it may seem, we�d like to see the inclusion of
some simple games, and we�d like to see a feature that lets you answer
or hang up the telephone by opening and closing the dialpad (fliplid) �
but that one could be difficult, because how would you use the Palm while
you�re on a call without hanging up?
Another area where the pdQ could stand improvement is in its HackMaster
application. The engineer who tested this product downloaded a few
shareware applications (including his personal favorite, TealEcho, which
makes Graffiti easier to use by providing visual feedback as the
characters are drawn, just like a real pen), but all of these programs
only worked for a few minutes and then caused fatal exception errors.
Those errors can only be fixed by performing a soft reboot or by removing
and reinstalling the lithium ion battery.
Finally, although it is available separately, we feel that the pdQ
should include a case with a belt clip, and it should be the kind that
doesn�t require removing the case to use the device.
We have one additional note: we�re told by a Qualcomm engineer that a
new version of the pdQ will be available for the 2000 holiday season. This
version will be based on a Palm V instead of a Palm III. The Palm V is
lighter, thinner, and faster than the Palm III, and it has more RAM � so
we can expect the next-generation pdQ to also have those attributes.
Rumors of a color screen have also crossed the desk of many technology
journalists, although that may be more than one generation removed.
Even better news is that rather than costing more, the Christmastime
pdQ will maintain the current price point, and today�s pdQ will be
discounted. By then, we hope to see Windows CE-based competition and
shareware written exclusively for the pdQ. (If you want to enhance this
product�s functions but you can�t wait until winter, fear not: Think
Outside, which makes the �Stowaway� folding PDA keyboard, might work
great with the pdQ. Visit their Web site at www.thinkoutside.com.)
CONCLUSION
The pdQ smartphone is a hands-down Editors� Choice award winner. We love
this thing. If you can afford one, we advise that you buy it. If you can
afford one but you already own a Palm VII and a state-of-the-art mobile
phone, then stop reading this article, sell your current devices on eBay,
and go back to the previous sentence. True, we have a healthy room for
improvement list, but we can�t think of any reason (beside the its
price) not to buy one.
It�s against our mission as journalists to give financial advice, but
if Palm hasn�t done an IPO by the time you read this, brace yourself! We
predict that if other platforms in the hybrid �communicator� space do
not shape up by the end of the year, then the pdQ and forthcoming versions
will enjoy the same success for the next five years as Windows enjoyed for
the past five. |