TMCnet News

Making hospital form follow function [Industrial Engineer]
[May 20, 2013]

Making hospital form follow function [Industrial Engineer]


(Industrial Engineer Via Acquire Media NewsEdge) Lean integrates with evidence-based design for healthier patients and improved ROI HEALTHCARE I S ONE OF THE MOST IMPORTANT, yet distressed, sectors of the U.S. economy. Total expenditures in healthcare are growing rapidly, from Si.6 trillion (14.9 percent of the gross domestic product) in 2002 to an estimated S3.6 trillion (18.4 percent of gross domestic product) by 2013.

The U.S. healthcare system is facing a convergence of the need to replace aging 1970s' hospitals, along with the introduction of new medical technologies and treatments that may require new facility designs. Meanwhile, quality continues to be a concern. In its landmark study, the Institute of Medicine reported that an estimated 44,000 to 98,000 people in the U.S. die annually from preventable medical errors.

Healthcare policymakers, healthcare professionals and architects are determined to create safe, efficient and effective hospitals for patients, their families and staff. A wide ranging set of actions has been taken at many levels to improve healthcare quality, reduce cost and provide the right access. At the federal and state levels, changes in policy and regulation are ongoing. On a more localized level, hospitals and other healthcare delivery organizations are taking a variety of actions to "bend the cost curve" downward for their institutions while simultaneously improving patient care and patient outcomes. This presents an opportunity to rethink the hospital design process.


A key challenge in hospital facility design is the fact that hospital administrators and architects often make critical design decisions grounded on experience-based intuition, sometimes neglecting to use evidence-based research. Looking to improve the design process by integrating more rigorous findings, many healthcare design professionals have embarked upon a new era of work that is centered on the following two initiatives.

First, healthcare has begun to embrace evidence-based design (EBD).Just as medicine has incorporated the use of research-based evidence to improve clinical decision making, healthcare facility design is moving to use rigorous research that links the characteristics of a hospital's physical environment to patient outcomes and employee performance. EBD has the potential to improve significantly the return on investments in hospital renovation, expansion and new construction.

A second healthcare initiative is the movement toward lean, the long-term philosophy of continuously and relentlessly driving out waste from systems. Based on principles developed for the automobile industry by Toyota Motor Corp., lean has been applied successfully in hospitals to improve quality, efficiency and safety.

After briefly introducing both initiatives and examining critical execution issues with the hospital design process in practice, we aim to demonstrate how these two initiatives - lean and EBD - can be integrated and executed in the context of hospital design.

Evidence-based design According to the Center for Health Design, EBD is an approach to healthcare that gives importance to design characteristics that affect the health, well-being, moods and safety of patients, their families and hospital staff. Kirk Hamilton and David Watkins, in theirbook Evidence-Based Design forMultiple Building Types, state that EBD is "the conscientious, explicit and judicious use of current best evidence from research and practice in making critical decisions, together with an informed client, about the design of each individual and unique project." In the past two decades, numerous EBD-driven hospital design interventions have enhanced patient safety and quality of care. Most of the EBD focus has been on reducing hospital-acquired infections, which is a major problem in hospitals and the focus of much attention by the medical community. Based on research findings in medical, technical and behavioral journals, architects have incorporated improvements in placing hand washing sinks and hand gel dispensers; the flow of air and water in patient areas, materials and surfaces amenable to infection control; and creating room layouts that protect patients from cross-contamination and infection transmission.

Again based on evidence from the literature, the patient room has been a significant focus of EBD interventions to improve patient care and well-being. Room designs have improved artificial and natural lighting, enhanced visibility to pleasing views of nature, reduced ambient noise and made space comfortable for visitors to stay with patients. These types of design interventions have been shown to improve the mental and physical states of patients, fostering healing and increasing patient satisfaction.

EBD also has addressed various needs of the hospital staff. Designs have been employed on patient floors and in ancillary departments to improve workflow and situation awareness and to reduce unwanted distractions, thereby increasing caregiver efficiency and decreasing workload and stress. Designs focused on patient-staffinteractions have been developed, where services are located in closer proximity to the patients being served. In addition, similar services are clustered togedier to improve the speed of service and the degree of coordination.

The way of continuous improvement In his book Hie Machine that Changed the World, James Womack tells us that the term "lean" was coined to describe an operating system that was able to produce manufactured goods with higher quality at half the cost and in half the time of traditional manufacturing methods.The goal of lean is to provide the desired amount of product or service at the highest possible level of quality with zero waste.

Lean is a continuous improvement philosophy founded on respect for people, individual empowerment and a set of system design principles. In their Harvard Business Review article, "Decoding the DNA of the Toyota Production System," H. Kent Bowen and Steven Spear uncovered a number of fundamental principles that should drive the lean system design. They note that lean defines systems in terms of sets of discrete activities and connections between these activities, all linked together in pathways to perform work. The objective is to streamline these pathways and make the activities and connections as simple and as standardized as possible.

A number of common lean system design practices, such as justin-time inventory, workload leveling and setup time reduction, are geared toward making work simpler to perform. Without standardization, one cannot add discipline to the culture, a frequendy tainted but essential element for lean system design.

At the operational level, lean is equipped with many tools.Two of the most popular in practice are value stream mapping (VSM) and kaizen events. VSMs graphically represent the key people, material and information flows required to deliver a product or service and are designed to distinguish value-adding from non-value-adding steps. These maps are used to identify areas of opportunity for rapid improvement through the use of kaizen events, which typically are two- to five-day activities where teams of employees engage in small cycles of improvement. Kaizen events are a critical component in implementing lean practices and lean design and help close the gap between an organization's desired and actual operating performance.

An example of one healthcare organization that successfully used lean in facilities design is Virginia Mason Hospital in Seattle. By using lean, Virginia Mason redesigned its current facilities and practices to create healing environments with better quality care at lower cost. According to the Center for Health Design and the Institute for Healthcare Improvement, lean principles can be and already are being applied successfully to the design of healthcare delivery systems. When designed well, lean healthcare systems should result in environments that promote excellent quality, safety and employee and patient satisfaction.

So conceptually it is clear that lean can add value to the EBD process. But what should this integration look like Critical hospital design execution issues Hospital administrators have limited budgets and must move rapidly to make facility improvements. The pace of competition is speeding up, and architects must meet this imperative for speed and cost efficiency. At the same time, cheaper and faster does not mean less involvement with key stakeholders. To produce designs that meet the needs of all parties, the spoken and unspoken expectations of customers, employees, suppliers, regulators, management and other outside constituents must be considered.

To understand and satisfy expectations, it is critical to be able to generate and explore design alternatives in a meaningful way. Stakeholders must be able to understand the trade-offs and implications of alternate designs and evaluate them accordingly. The criteria each stakeholder group uses could differ and might include considerations of financial impact, safety, security, productivity, aesthetics and style, user experience, consistency with adjacent structures, and so on. The variety of criteria that exist make design iterations likely, as it will be difficult to get it right the first time.

Hospitals are not cookie-cutter facilities; every hospital is designed differently and has its own set of priorities, strategies and operating objectives. A focus of the EBD movement in general is the emphasis on tyingevidence to design choices. This answers the important question of what existing evidence should be reviewed for a particular design. However, it does not clearly answer the equally important question ofwhen and how new evidence should be generated and incorporated into design projects. In other words, to date EBD has focused much more on addressing design issues and less on offering guidance on how to generate relevant new evidence while working with healthcare professionals. Answering the question of when and how to generate and incorporate evidence into the design process requires exploration cycles during EBD execution, using lean to drive these exploration cycles.

The integration Using the Center for Health Design's model for EBD as a base, Figure 1 offers a high-level perspective of where lean and EBD can be integrated. It shows that EBD is integrated into each of the five steps in a typical design and construction engagement process.

The first step is to discover the goals and objectives a client has for a project. This usually includes an assessment of organizational readiness, including ideas of how evidence could be used to enhance the project. During the second step, pre-design, EBD focuses on prioritizing key design issues suited to research investigation for which the practitioner lacks appropriate information and then finding relevant sources of evidence. The information search includes books, research articles, white papers and research presentations from a variety of industries such as architecture, construction, aviation, manufacturing, military and food production. This requires skills in understanding and interpreting research results, so that only verified and valid evidence is considered for specific design questions.

In the third step - design - EBD activities are geared toward critically interpreting the gathered evidence and developing and evaluating innovative design concepts that incorporate that evidence. This is done through creating distinct design hypotheses that focus on distinct issues for which the practitioner can collect baseline performance data, thereby testing the hypotheses. The fourth and fifth steps - construction and occupancy - which are outside the scope of this article, are to construct and then perform post-occupancy analysis to check if the built facility meets preestablished expectations.

In practice, steps one and two often focus on master planning as well as conceptual/functional diagramming and space programming, which describe the basic assumptions regarding space and throughput capacity needs. Other design activities at these stages include developing the project budget and schedule and selecting the project team members, such as interior designers, contractors and so on.

Step three focuses more on schematic design involving furniture, fixtures, equipment and technology planning.

While Figure 1 presents a linear and streamlined process, the Center for Health Design emphasizes that this is a simplified model and that translating EBD steps into practice often is not a linear process. The shaded portion of Figure 1 can be viewed as a design process where architects and a selected group of client stakeholders define goals and objectives, generate design concepts based on identified issues of importance, conduct research and critically interpret the findings, and eventually select the most preferred concept to move forward into design, development and construction.

Of course, this assumes that the most preferred concept is acceptable to all parties, which may not be the case. If all the developed concepts fail to meet the stated goals and objectives, iteration is required and the design process begins again, either from step one, two or three. Such potential iterations often are frustrating as they add significant time and cost to the project and require additional effort from stakeholders to rework design concepts. Thus, in practice, hospital administrators operating under tight budgetary constraints often push hard to keep the design process moving forward in order to eliminate costly iterations. This could result in solutions that are completed on time and within budget, but fail to meet the true needs of those who will operate in the completed facilities.

The challenge, then, is to define a healthcare facility design process that incorporates evidence in a meaningful way, allows for exploration and evaluation of multiple design concepts, and yet is cost-efficient and timely. If one thinks about lean as an important source of evidence for EBD, then the integration of lean into EBD provides an opportunity to address this challenge. Figure 2 presents an EBD design process with lean exploration loops, thereby creating a "lean-EBD" design process.

At a high level, the approach in Figure 2 generates broad sets of design alternatives, which allow architects to begin the EBD design process concurrently with receiving valuable information from lean exploration loops, gradually narrowing the design alternatives and increasing the level of design details until an optimum design is revealed and refined. The goal underpinning the use of lean exploration loops during the EBD process is the opportunity to postpone critical decisions while moving through the three critical EBD process design gates, namely, the footprint planning gate, the layout planning gate and final design selection gate.

The execution So how should one execute the lean-EBD process One of the key lean-EBD design principles is to "look forward," exploring the operational ramifications of possible designs while there still is design flexibility. By testing and evaluating alternate designs prior to making gate decisions, the process has a built-in flexibility that should yield improved design outcomes while still proceeding as rapidly as possible through the design process.

Some critical actions must be taken for lean-EBD integration to succeed. Creating an engaged team consisting of senior leadership, architects and one or more lean experts is perhaps the first critical step required. From the perspective of the hospital professionals, lean-EBD is a new process being introduced into its work environment, thereby bringing change into the organization. A large body of research literature on new process introduction and change management demonstrates the critical roles that senior leadership must play in situations such as this.

At a minimum, senior leadership must provide visible and tangible support for the transition from the conventional way of doing facility design projects to the new lean-EBD approach. This often requires senior leadership to become knowledgeable on lean and EBD, at least enough to understand its potential benefits, and then to communicate the value of lean-EBD to the key project stakeholders. Senior leadership must also recognize that while making the transition to lean-EBD likely will add time and initial cost to the project, these investments should pay offin improved design outcomes and enhanced system performance.

Lean design activities included in estimating space requirements and/or throughput capacity should be launched early, during the organizational readiness phase of EBD. This will help in comprehending the operational upside of lean system design, which should minimize or eliminate cost paralysis and premature decision making from hospital leadership teams. Lean experts, by closely working with architects and hospital professionals, should be effective in using computer simulation software to pre-generate alternate footprints and space programs (or layouts) to predict capacity needs.calculate throughputs, identify bottlenecks and find opportunities for service leveling, incorporation of pull systems and other critical system design features.

In the pre-design phase of EBD, lean offers a variety of formalized approaches. For initial high level schematic design efforts, which include design visioning and conceptualization, a VSM coupled with production preparation planning (often referred to as "3P") is probably the best front-end choice. These VSM and 3P activities typically involve a diverse group of individuals, including patients, doctors, leaders, nurses and other front-line professionals, in a multiple-day event to identify several breakthrough design concepts. Open and honest discussion about past system failures and patient harms, without fear of punishment or embarrassment, must become pan of this second lean exploration loop.

Finally, to help with the design phase of EBD, probably the most granular level of lean design could be found in kaizen rapid improvement events, used to break apart and put together designed layouts, operational processes, technologies, etc. At this detailed level of analysis, the lean teams can try to implement and test designs in mock-up spaces using role playing. Kaizen events can be used to examine and evaluate alternate schematic designs and make further improvement suggestions for location of furniture, fixtures, equipment, technology and other interior details. Kaizen events are team-based practices grounded in measurable evidence that use the principles of testability as proposed by the scientific method. Every piece of the designed system, process, layout and technology is tested for effectiveness. This fits well with the philosophy of EBD.

In summary, diligent execution of the lean-EBD process should offer excellent solutions that satisfy all stakeholders. The exploration loops embedded in the lean-EBD process provide a balance between the creative exploration of design ideas and an efficient, structured push toward project completion.

Conclusions Implementing a lean-EBD process requires major change throughout an entire organization, which can be difficult. Strong commitment and inspiring leadership from senior leaders are first steps toward successful lean-EBD implementation.The lean-EBD process must be transparent, supportive and committed to learning. The leadership team, doctors and nurses must place patient and staffsafety as a priority and make sure patients and families are fully engaged in the design.

Hospital administrators expect timely designs provided through low cost engagements. Therefore, the evidence gathering and evaluation effort must be as streamlined as possible, while still allowing the team to explore alternatives and iterate designs that are informed by evidence. All of this suggests a lean-EBD process structure, which front-loads the process of design with lean exploration loops designed to generate, test and evaluate design concepts rapidly.

Although many other ideas and architectural actions are needed to bring about the design of a complex hospital, these recommendations are essential for successfully implementing lean principles and tools during the EBD process. Organizations that follow the lean-EBD process will be well on their way to occupying physical facility designs that promote high efficiency, reliability and safety.

bikaszMazur is an assistant professor at the Radiation Oncology Department in the School 0] Medicine at the University 0/ North Carolina and is involved with HE's Society for Engineering and Management Systems (SEMS). His research, teaching and consulting expertise is focused on healthcare engineering management, including organizational learning, patient safety and quality improvement models, and hospital design.

John McCivciy is an associate professor and director of the Master of Global Innovation Management program at North Carolina State University's Poole College of Management. He has worked in the IT consulting and medical device industries, saving in engineering, operations and leadership positions. His areas oj research include business process improvement, aitical thinking skill development and healthcare performance excellence.

Mark Vaughan is a senior principal with WHRAixhilects in charge of its Dallas office and team leader Jor its healthcare design studio. He has more than 27 yean of architectuntl experience with direct involvement in developing more than 2 million square feet of healthcare-related institutional work in the last jive years. His work has involved campus and facility master planning and architectural programming, planning and design for numerous institutional projects, including complex multiphased renovation, expansion and newgreenjicld hospitals.

Chad Lefteris is a vice president of operations at Rex Healthcare responsible for construction and design, real estate portfolio, jacililies, culinary services emiironmentalservices, ambulance transport, security, customer service, operationalimprovement andthe oncology service line. He has more than is yearsof experience working with architects on hospital facility design projects.

(c) 2013 Institute of Industrial Engineers-Publisher

[ Back To TMCnet.com's Homepage ]